The sale and import of all iPhones and iPads with 5G support have been banned in Colombia. The ban comes via a preliminary injunction granted to Ericsson over a standard essential patent.
FOSS Patents reports...
The Juzgado 043 Civil del Circuito de Bogotá--a court in the Colombian capital of Bogotá--found Apple's 5G iPhones and iPads to infringe claim 13 of Colombian patent no. NC2019/0003681, which has been declared essential to the 5G standard and was granted to Ericsson in 2019 and will remain valid until December 2037.
The preliminary injunction bars Apple from importing, selling, commercializing, and advertising the iPhone and iPad. Apple must also "warn and communicate with "shops, retailers, owners of social media platforms, mass media, and e-commerce platforms to ensure compliance. The affected devices are various iPhone 12 and 13 models, as well as newer iPads.
Additionally, Judge Ronald Neil Orozco Gómez says Apple may not seek or enforce antisuit injunction from another country to prevent or restrict Ericsson's enforcement of the Colombian injunction. This is called an anti-antisuit injunction. In an effort to circumvent this, Apple's lawyers are seeking antisuit damages in the Eastern District of Texas. The company says the Colombian injunction gives Ericsson "economic and logistical leverage [...] to pressure Apple to abandon this litigation and capitulate to Ericsson’s [royalty] demand." Apple has asked Chief Judge Rodney S. Gilstrap to rule that Ericsson must "indemnify Apple from any fines, fees, penalties, and costs it incurs as a result of the Colombian injunction."
This case is just a part of a major legal battle between Ericsson and Apple over FRAND essential patents. Late last year, Ericsson asked the Eastern District of Texas to declare that Ericsson's royalty rate of $5 per device is FRAND and that Ericsson's overall conduct is FRAND-compliant. This request came months before an existing agreement with Apple over royalty rates was set to expire.
You can learn more about the case at the link below...
Read More
FOSS Patents reports...
The Juzgado 043 Civil del Circuito de Bogotá--a court in the Colombian capital of Bogotá--found Apple's 5G iPhones and iPads to infringe claim 13 of Colombian patent no. NC2019/0003681, which has been declared essential to the 5G standard and was granted to Ericsson in 2019 and will remain valid until December 2037.
The preliminary injunction bars Apple from importing, selling, commercializing, and advertising the iPhone and iPad. Apple must also "warn and communicate with "shops, retailers, owners of social media platforms, mass media, and e-commerce platforms to ensure compliance. The affected devices are various iPhone 12 and 13 models, as well as newer iPads.
Additionally, Judge Ronald Neil Orozco Gómez says Apple may not seek or enforce antisuit injunction from another country to prevent or restrict Ericsson's enforcement of the Colombian injunction. This is called an anti-antisuit injunction. In an effort to circumvent this, Apple's lawyers are seeking antisuit damages in the Eastern District of Texas. The company says the Colombian injunction gives Ericsson "economic and logistical leverage [...] to pressure Apple to abandon this litigation and capitulate to Ericsson’s [royalty] demand." Apple has asked Chief Judge Rodney S. Gilstrap to rule that Ericsson must "indemnify Apple from any fines, fees, penalties, and costs it incurs as a result of the Colombian injunction."
This case is just a part of a major legal battle between Ericsson and Apple over FRAND essential patents. Late last year, Ericsson asked the Eastern District of Texas to declare that Ericsson's royalty rate of $5 per device is FRAND and that Ericsson's overall conduct is FRAND-compliant. This request came months before an existing agreement with Apple over royalty rates was set to expire.
You can learn more about the case at the link below...
Read More